Do You Have to Pay Factor Fees? Your Obligations and Your Options in Scotland

Yes. If a property factor has been validly appointed under your title deeds or by a majority of owners under the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004, every owner must pay their share of the common costs, and the liability attaches to the flat. You cannot opt out individually, but you can dispute a specific charge in writing and take it to the Housing and Property Chamber.

Sarah Morrison, Co-Founder & CEO
Sarah Morrison
7
min read
Last reviewed
November 9, 2026
Share this post:
Do You Have to Pay Factor Fees? Your Obligations and Your Options in Scotland

The question arrives in a few forms. A new owner who did not know the flat came with a factor. A long-standing owner who has stopped trusting the invoices. A stair that wonders whether it could simply do without. The honest answer has two halves: whether you are obliged to pay at all, which is a question about your title deeds and the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004, and what you can do when you think a charge is wrong, which is a question about procedure. This guide covers both, and then the related question of whether a block can manage itself.

Do you have to pay factor fees?

Yes, if a factor has been validly appointed for your building. The obligation does not come from the factor; it comes from your title deeds, which usually provide for a factor and oblige each owner to pay a share of the common costs, or from a decision of the owners under the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004, which binds every owner including those who voted against.

Either way the liability attaches to the flat. You cannot opt out individually, you cannot decline the parts of the service you do not use, and the obligation passes to whoever buys the flat from you. What you can do, and should, is challenge any specific charge that is wrong.

Where does the obligation come from?

The title deeds. Most flats in Scotland have a deed of conditions or equivalent that names the common parts, says how costs are shared, and either appoints a factor or provides for one to be appointed. Those are real burdens: they run with the land and bind each owner in turn. If your deeds say the owners shall employ a factor and pay its charges, the invoice is enforcing your own title.

The Tenement Management Scheme. Where the deeds are silent, the 2004 Act's default scheme applies. A majority of flats can decide to appoint a factor, and the Act makes each owner liable for their share of scheme costs. A properly made scheme decision binds owners who voted no and owners who never replied. Our guide to who pays for common repairs explains how the shares are set.

A development management scheme or owners' association. Some modern estates have a formal scheme under the Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003 with its own rules. The effect is the same: membership comes with the flat, and so does the bill.

What happens if you do not pay the factor?

The factor's Written Statement of Services and its debt recovery procedure set the sequence, and the Code of Conduct for Property Factors requires the procedure to be in writing and applied consistently. The usual steps are reminders, then a late payment charge if the Written Statement provides for one, then formal letters, then court action under the Simple Procedure for sums up to £5,000 and a decree that can be enforced by arrestment of wages or bank funds. Interest may be sought at the judicial rate once a court has decided the case.

Two things are specific to flats and worth knowing. A factor, or the other owners, can register a Notice of Potential Liability for Costs against your title, which warns any buyer that unpaid common costs attach to the flat and in practice makes a sale very difficult until the arrears are settled.

And the Tenements Act lets the other owners recover an unpaid share from the defaulting owner, which is why a persistent non-payer finds the neighbours as motivated as the factor. Our guide to missing shares looks at it from the building's side.

Can you withhold factor fees if you are unhappy with the service?

You can, but it is the weakest move available and it usually makes things worse. Withholding the whole invoice over one disputed line leaves your neighbours covering the shortfall, triggers the debt recovery procedure, and hands the factor a simple debt claim in which the quality of the cleaning is not a defence. The law gives you better tools.

Dispute the specific charge in writing and say why. Pay the rest. Use the factor's complaints procedure, which the Code requires it to have and to answer within set timescales. If the answer does not come or does not fix it, apply to the Housing and Property Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland.

There is no fee, you do not need a solicitor, and the Chamber can order the factor to refund a charge, carry out work or pay compensation. A factor should not pursue interest or recovery on a sum that is in genuine dispute and before the Chamber, and a decision in your favour is published with the factor's name.

Which charges can you refuse?

Not charges you dislike, but charges that have no basis. A charge is challengeable where the Written Statement of Services did not provide for it, where the work was not authorised under the deeds or the Scheme and was not an emergency, where your share has been calculated on the wrong basis, where a late payment charge is not reasonable or not in the Written Statement, or where the factor cannot produce the contractor invoice behind a repair line.

Ask for the source: which deed clause sets my share, which decision authorised this work, which contractor invoice is this. A factor with the answers will give them. Our guide to reading a factor invoice shows what each line should look like.

Can a block of flats manage itself without a factor?

Sometimes, and only if the owners are honest about the work. Nothing in Scots law requires a building to be factored unless the deeds say so. Where the deeds are silent, or allow the owners to run things themselves, the Tenement Management Scheme gives a stair everything it needs: majority decisions, default cost shares and a way to recover an unpaid share from a neighbour.

What the Scheme does not supply is a person. Self-management works in a small, simple building where one or two owners will hold the buildings insurance, collect the shares, instruct the repairs, keep the records and chase the neighbour who is late, and where the other owners pay on time.

It stops working where there is a lift, a heat network, cladding, a gated car park, commercial units or more than a dozen or so flats, because somebody has to carry the statutory inspections, the duty holder role for fire safety and the client money, and the volunteer who takes that on unpaid usually stops after the second year, often when a large bill lands and the neighbours turn on them.

If you are weighing it up, the practical test is this: name the person who will do the work, name the account the money will sit in, and name what happens when one flat does not pay. If all three have answers, self-management is a real option. If not, the question is which factor, not whether. Our guide to changing factor covers both routes.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay factor fees if I did not sign anything?

Yes. The obligation comes from the title deeds you took on when you bought the flat, or from a decision of the owners under the Tenements Act, not from a contract you signed with the factor. Your solicitor should have flagged the factoring arrangement before you bought.

Do I have to pay factor fees for a flat I rent out?

Yes. The owner pays the factor; the tenant does not. You can build the cost into the rent, but the factor's invoice, and any arrears, are yours.

Can a factor charge me for work I did not agree to?

For routine maintenance within the authority limit in the Written Statement of Services, and for emergency and safety work, yes. For larger work the decision should have been made by the owners under the deeds or the Scheme, usually by majority, and if it was, it binds you even if you voted against. If no decision was made and it was not an emergency, challenge it.

Can I be charged interest on factor fees?

A late payment charge can be applied if the Written Statement of Services sets it out and it is reasonable. Interest on a debt is normally awarded by a court after a decree. A factor should not add either to a sum that is genuinely in dispute and before the Housing and Property Chamber.

What happens to arrears when I sell?

They have to be settled. Your solicitor will ask the factor for a statement, and the buyer's solicitor will check for a Notice of Potential Liability for Costs on the title. Unpaid common costs can follow the flat, so sales with arrears outstanding tend to stall until they are cleared from the proceeds.

General information only. Individual title deeds and circumstances differ.

AboveBoard Homes is an Edinburgh property factor that publishes its fees, its debt recovery procedure and its complaints procedure in full. If your invoice raises a question your factor will not answer, get in touch.

See What We Can Do for You

Contact us today to learn how we can help you achieve your goals with our services.

Side-by-side of dry, patchy grass next to lush, healthy grass — showing the difference proactive property maintenance makes